Avon vs. BeautyCounter vs. Mary Kay vs. Tastefully Simple

Avon BeautyCounter Mary Kay Tastefully Simple
Name

Avon

BeautyCounter

Mary Kay

Tastefully Simple

User Rating

    
8 review(s)

Vote

    
9 review(s)

Vote

    
41 review(s)

Vote

    
1 review(s)

Vote
Year Founded 1886 2013 1963 1995
Est. # Reps 2,000,000 50,000 1,700,000 28,000
Base Commission 40% 20% - 35% 50% 30%
Downline Commission -- 5% - 9% 13% 5%
Startup Cost $10 $85 $100 $89
Products Sold Cosmetics, Makeup, Face Care, Masques, Perfume -- -- --
Details More Details » More Details » More Details » More Details »

User Reviews

5     
wrote 8 years ago

No other skincare products have consistently delivered results I could depend on. I know I could spend more on other brands, but I won't get more for what I spend. I have confidence that I am using the very best in skincare on the market today.

Helpful (2)
5     
wrote 7 years ago

AVON!!!! Speaks for itself, just lookl how old the company is and the success they have. No one can grow to this size having poor quality. As far as Busy Beane I'm honest as the day is long, hard working, and always putting others first.

Helpful (1)
5     
wrote 7 years ago

Started using MK @ 11yrs old for my skin. Became a consultant at 18 to help put a single mom through college. At 44, 2 successful adult children and 1 more still in college, 2 grandkids & and 24 yr marriage blessed by the values of Faith, Family, & Career being a focus; Mary Kay is still a tradition thats beauty is much deeper than makeup. The philosopher Cicero once said, "The face is a picture of the mind as the eyes are its interpreter." Itheater is an honor & privilege to have relationships w/ my clients. Skin care & make-up is merely the Avenue to which I put more smile...

Helpful (1)
5     
wrote 7 years ago

I have used Mary Kay products going on 6 years now and I LOVE them. I have tried a few other products but they DO NOT COMPARE to the quality of what Mary Kay products are. I finally joined the Mary Kay Business after 5 years of being a customer. Man, I wish I would of joined sooner. I have heard Mary Kay is expensive and to be honest they are not. I bought the Timewise Set and It has lasted me 7 months!!!! I have had people tell me that my skin looks great and even tone :). I believe Mary Kay is the BEST as far as the Products and the Business plan!

Helpful (1)
5     
wrote 8 years ago

I'm loving my Avon business. I hated sales but for some reason, this comes very naturally for me. As a natural leader, I've been able to coach many other young ladies on the marketing aspect of direct sales. Thanks for having a site with all of them in one space!

Helpful (1)
5     
wrote 7 years ago

I love what I do! I love what I sell! I love meeting new people and I live to be the best customer service you have had work with you or assist you!

Helpful (1)
5     
wrote 5 years ago

My mom was an AVON Lady when I was a kid, I'm an AVON Lady now raising MY kids! Grandmas recognize AVON because they have trusted in the products their entire lives. AVON has proven it's worth for nearly 150 years, and we don't rely on high prices to pretend we have quality products, we have generations of loyal customers and reps to prove we have quality products.

Helpful (1)
5     
wrote 8 years ago

My go to. They have been around forever and treat you like family. Great products and a company I can stand behind

Helpful (1)
5     
wrote 9 years ago

Beautycounter is such a wonderful company with a wonderful mission. I feel great selling their products and knowing that what I'm selling is safe and effective. The compensation is great, too, and there is lots of support.

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 8 years ago

Talk about a company that cares about the health of their customers. Not only are the products high performing, they are safe. They promise not to use 1500 potentially harmful ingredients.

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 9 years ago

I LOVE BeautyCounter products! Very excited about this opportunity. Leading the Change in Jacksonville.

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 8 years ago

Tastefully Simple meal kits are amazing! They make dinners so much easier and everything is delicious!

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 7 years ago

I love Mary Kay because it is trusted brand, in the market for 53 years. The products are made in the US and made with the best ingredients. I love my skincare! I love how my skin feels, people tell me I look 10- 15 years younger! Also Mary Kay people are always positive and happy, I love my Mary Kay! :)

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 8 years ago

Beautycounter's mission is to create safer, but luxurious and effective skin care and cosmetics for women and their families. Beautycounter is 100% committed to formulating products that do not contain ANY toxic ingredients that are linked to human health issues such as learning disabilities, cancer, hormonal disruption, infertility, asthma, etc... Best of all, the products really perform! I have had wonderful results!

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 7 years ago

Because hello it's mary Kay people not only is it an amazing company to work for but you don't have come workers you have sisters a support team and we are the only company the makes 50% of everything we sell unlike other you take profit away from other people!

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 8 years ago

I have been a consultant for almost 2 years now, I initially came in for the extra income. However after attending my first Career Conference, I found that this company offers a woman SO much more than skin care and makeup...acceptance, a sisterhood, and an overabundance of support!! So I came into Mary Kay for the money, but I am staying for the sisterhood!!

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 8 years ago

I love the company been a consultant for just two months I love the rewards you get from it and the fact you can work when ever you want

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 8 years ago

I have been a Mary Consultant for 39 years. Started out to earn just a little income to add to the family budget. However like so many I found I could do better. I am living the MK dream. Great products, great clients,great unit. Thank you, Mary Kay !

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 8 years ago

In my opinion, Mary Kay is the BEST company around! I will be celebrating my 10 year anniversary in May and this opportunity has forever changed my life! I started out as a broke college student and I was able to retire from teaching to do what I absolutely love... Building confidence in women and enriching women's lives with this wonderful opportunity! Mary Kay is number one on the list and it does not surprise me one bit! If you are willing to have a positive attitude and you are coachable, the sky is the limit for YOU! Thank you Mary Kay!

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 8 years ago

A + income opportunity, top notch products at reasonable prices that are ALWAYS on trend, mentoring and training that personally develops the sales force continuously! The corporate staff are so supportive that I just cannot believe it. I only started a business to see what would happen and didn't even have a goal in mind, but caught this company's passion and mission and am thriving ever since. The financial rewards are great and appreciated, but the personal development, joy, networking, friendships, and flexibility were all bonuses far more valuable to me than I knew. + I love my skin!

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 8 years ago

It changes life! Amazing products, Amazing opportunity! Blessed to be in the MK family since 4 years!

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 8 years ago

I started selling Avon almost 3 years ago for extra money and to put recent work experience on my resume. I fell in love with the products. I started using the skin care products and wearing jewelry. I love the holiday items. They sell well as do the signature Avon products like Skin So Soft. I will probably continue to sell Avon even after I find full-time work just because I love the products. Avon provides excellent support to their sales representatives; I couldn't ask for a better District Sales Manager. She had led me the whole way and I still turn to her for answers. I LOVE AVON!!!

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 8 years ago

Amazing Products! Have used for 27 years! Best that MK comes with an educated Consultant and a 100% satisfaction guarantee!

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 8 years ago

Because God is First, Family Second, Career 3 all the products are the best and the guarantee is 100%. And the commission are the best!

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 8 years ago

I will be eternally grateful that I signed my Consultant Agreement in 1970... Absolutely the best Company and latest on trend Products. Priorities of Family second, and Career third ..allowing me to build a good solid Career with ...Executive income while working flexible hours, earning free use of Career Cars,(Pink Cadillacs )New every 2 years since 1980! Loving my life! PTL!!

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 7 years ago

My girlfriend has tried just about every brand out there and raves about Mary Kay!

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 8 years ago

I previously used those department store brands for years at great expense and finally realized they weren't helping my skin. I used Mary Kay's Miracle Set for 1 week and I was amazed at how much better my skin felt and looked.

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 8 years ago

As someone who has previously worked for Younique for 3 years and have extensive knowledge about their products I have got to say Beautycounter is hands down a higher class of skincare and cosmetics. You just can't beat the safety and high performance of Beautycounter products. Not only do the not use 1500 potentially harmful ingredients that other brands including Younique and others use, we lobby to see change in the laws and regulations in government. We believe no woman should have to choose between feeling beautiful and being safe. Beautycounters compensation plan is also very lucrative.

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 7 years ago

Jau 10 metų naudoju šios kompanijos produktus. Esu patenkinta kaip atrodau ir žinau, kad mano oda yra visapusiškai prižiūrėta. Žaviuosi kompanijos filisofija, vizija bei misija. Mary Kay Ash sukūrė tai, ko labiausiai reikia moterims.

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 7 years ago

Mary Kay has the best quality at a reasonable price. You get a 100% return guarantee - not only for 14 days! - but as long as there is a small left over remains in the container. AND: The Mary Kay marketing plan is the most rewarding in the direct selling. It has been a reliable Partner since so many years for millions of women. 80% of all female selmade-millionairs are Mary Kay Consultants. So why would anyone want to work with younique??

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 8 years ago

Beautycounter is a company that not only sells fantastic high performing products but is on a mission to change the industry. Beautycounter is trying to help create laws to protect us from chemicals that are in our products.

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 8 years ago

I started using Beautycounter products after I was diagnosed with a fibroadenoma in my left breast. I began researching causes and links to cancer and similar conditions and was shocked at what I learned. I was used to very high performing products and had tried organic brands that just didn't perform to my expectations. Once I tried Beautycounter, I fell in love - with the products and the mission! I decided to join the mission, first as a Band of Beauty member then as a consultant...and I've been loving it ever since! Such a great company and cause!

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 8 years ago

I have been selling avon for 16 years and the old saying I sell it because I love the products truly applies here. I can't imagine life without my avon products. Such great quality products for more than reasonable prices. Joining avon was a great decision! I also recently started the leadership program with Avon Canada- signing new representatives, just renews my excitement for these products and this company.

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 8 years ago

What an opportunity of a lifetime!! The support from Corporate is amazing. The products are truly the best out there backed by a 100% guarantee and great customer service. The quality of the products is above and beyond, the results women (and men) see when using our skin care products is phenomenal. The training that Corporate provides for us is amazing, we have every tool needed to make this career a success. With the recognizable Pink Cadillac's as a sign of success, what women achieve on the inside when pursuing their Mary Kay career is life changing. Fabulous company!

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 8 years ago

I've been using Mary Kay for 40 years. I've been an Independent Beauty Consultant for 7 years and still wonder why I waited so long.

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 8 years ago

You get 50% sales! They've been around a lot longer and both companies are debt free, but Mary Kay teaches how to get debt free!

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 7 years ago

I have tried several Mary Kay products and when I stop using Mary Kay and use drugstore brands I totally miss Mary Kay. Even though some of their items are more expensive they are definitely worth it. When I go back to using Mary Kay I can tell the difference. My skin totally reacts differently when using Mary Kay. Some drugstore products are OK and some are definitely not, then I start using Mary Kay. I absolutely love their moisturizers and the firming eye cream. The moisturizing eyemake up remover is absolutely the best! The revealing radiance facial peel I absolutely love!

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 7 years ago

PROVEN Success Record and a Company who stands behind their Product and their Consultants.

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 7 years ago

I have been using Avon off and on for many many years. I remember when my mother had an Avon lady so I feel great about a company that has been around for a lifetime. The products are great and you can not beat the prices any where. I have never tried R&F but I do not like spending a ton on products. I wear minimal makeup and always get complimented on my skin and look years younger than I am. Avon is perfect for me and there are endless products and anyone can open a catalog and say - yes I need that! I had the Moisture therapy hand lotion on my desk at work and everyone loves!

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 7 years ago

Los valores que inculcan a sus consultoras y el margen de ganancia es increíble.

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 7 years ago

After using Mary Kay since college for the past 32 years - and having seen and been inside the manufacturing plant and having met the President and founder of the company I can say without a doubt that Mary Kay is the BEST opportunity for women today bar none! :-)

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 7 years ago

I LOVE Mary Kay! I have been a consultant for 19 years, And I have been using the products for 37 years. I Love talking to women about this AMAZING skin care.

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 7 years ago

I have been faithfully using Beautycounter for the past three years. They use quality ingredients that are screened for safety and chosen for performance. I have extremely sensitive skin and Beautycounter provides a full line of skin care and personal care products for my family.

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 8 years ago

Reasons MK is the best: You get to try before you buy The products are high quality and yet very affordable It was founded on the golden rule Consultants make 50% off of every $ that is the highest in direct sales!!! You can win a car Have I mentioned how amazing the products are? I sell Mary Kay and it was the best decision I ever made. And when you become a consultant they have a 90% buy back! So you can start your company for no great risk to you or your finances! Might be biased but I did my research and Mary Kay proves to be the best DS out there! What a legacy to be apart of!

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 8 years ago

Love the company, the products, the mission: Uplift, Empower, Validate!

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 7 years ago

Beautycounter's products are completely safe and free of over 1500 different chemicals that could potentially lead to infertility, asthma, and cancer to just name a few. They have a wonderful mission to change the beauty industries regulations to help get safe products into the hands of everyone! Their products are gentle and high performing! I've become obsessed!!!

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 7 years ago

I was a consultant for Mary Kay for nearly 8 years and loved it! Now thinking of getting back into it especially due to the higher commissions than the others!

Helpful (0)
3     
wrote 7 years ago

I must preface this review by saying that I love Avon. I really truly do. The 3 stars I have as a rating are not a reflection on the company as a whole or it's products. The rating is simply based on the fact that when I was an Avon consultant, I barely made any money doing it. It wasn't worth the time, energy and my own money that I put into the business. If the pay structure was different, I would likely go back. I really do love their products.

Helpful (0)
4     
wrote 7 years ago

As a freelance make up artist I have used several lines and find these all have great products. I have used more Mary Kay but have tried Younique and LimeLight products and found them to be good also. The only complaint I have with these companies is the compensation plans are not great for the average person to realistically succeed. Too many people needed to make a decent income. I have found something that pays 4 times more with 75% less people AND we get 100% of our entire teams production. It's about helping others in any business, Best wishes to all.

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 8 years ago

Mary Kay is the best! It gave me an amazing life style growing up as a MK kid with my mom a top Cadillac director and now gives so much to my own family's life...more than just an income, a life style & relationships to last a lifetime!

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 8 years ago

Totally agree except to my knowledge Mary Kay never sold clothes ?? I've been with Mary Kay for over 20 years , having tried other companies, I can honestly say it's by far the best company! Yes, the income potential is amazing but it's our culture that truly stands out. MK is about enriching women's lives, creating a positive & rewarding environment for personal growth, & letting women live out the values of God, family, career while building a career . So Grateful that I was able to raise my 3 boys , work around my husband's schedule & build a successful business for over 22 ye...

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 8 years ago

I fell in love with Mary Kay products over 22 years ago when I became a consultant for this company. I was hooked the first time I used the skin care and cosmetics. Nothing I've tried has come close to the radiant glow that Mary Kay products give me! I haven't found another direct sales company where I can make 50% profit and earn commissions, prizes, awards, trips, and earn the use of a free car! Would I do it all over again? Absolutely! Mary Kay: I'm here to stay! Thank you for empowering women to put God first, family second and career third!

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 8 years ago

Great products! Great customer service! Great prices! I love everything about Mary Kay skin care and makeup! Everything smells pleasant!

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 8 years ago

Often imitated because of the success of the company for over 50 years; but can not be duplicated because of the faith, vision, values and ethics passed down from the founder. Simple plan that is all about helping others succeed, feel beautiful and condiedent while you do the same. It is not a get rich quick scheme- but rather a build wealth over time opportunity that works when you work it! Amazing products. Amazing opportunity .

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 7 years ago

Mary Kay Volufirm has transformed my skin. I work outdoors daily as a horseback riding instructor. Since using this regimen my sun damage and fine lines have vanished. I am 40 but my skin is better now than when I was 30. ALL I ever wear now is mascara. I get lots of compliments on my skin. I love it!!!

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 7 years ago

Avon is the original and the #1 direct sales company worldwide. It's that simple. I love their products, the quality and the price.

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 7 years ago

Mary Kay is a great product and the prices are very affordable results are great . I have also used Nerium it is also a good product the Firming Body cream is the best in my book. But the prices are a bet to high and you have to order every month. Mary can to can buy when and how ever much or little you want that's great... not trying to steep on ant toes here. Thank you.

Helpful (0)
5     
wrote 7 years ago

Mary Kay is a company that cares about more than mascara and lipstick. It is amazing to see all of the good they do for their consultants, customers, and grant winners. Check out the Mary Kay Ash foundation and all of their givings in your local area! You would be surprised!

Helpful (0)
2     
wrote 8 years ago

Mary kay is not a starter make up. There is a lot to finding the perfevt match of anything with mary kay. And its not as chemical free. There is nothing wrong with mary kay . Its not a bad company. But with my experience the make up is not for me. But their make up remover is the bam.com okay. If you have not tried it. Try it.

Helpful (0)

Which Direct Sales Company is Your Favorite?

You must be logged in to submit a review.

Sign Up with Facebook

Please enter your name and email address below to sign up.

Already a Member? Sign In

Login with Facebook

Please enter your email address and password below to login.

Title

Text